Christmas at the Amish Bakery

After leaving her Amish roots behind in her youth, Sarah, a seasoned New York book editor, finds herself facing a professional crisis. With Christmas fast approaching, she is under pressure to find a new cookbook that could save her job. The publishing world is fiercely competitive, and Sarah needs to bring something fresh to the table. Desperate for a solution, she decides to return to her childhood home, an Amish farm nestled in a quiet rural community, to reconnect with her roots and seek inspiration.

Back at the farm, Sarah is surrounded by the familiar sights and smells of her family’s Amish bakery. Although the bakery has been a staple of the community for years, it is struggling to stay afloat, especially in the face of modern competition. Sarah’s return is not only a chance to rediscover her heritage but also a way to help revive the family business. As she spends time in the bakery, she realizes that the rich traditions of Amish cooking could be the very thing she needs for her cookbook project.

However, Sarah’s journey home is complicated by the presence of Ben, a charming local who isn’t Amish but has forged a strong relationship with the community. His friendly, easygoing nature makes him well-liked among the Amish, and he is deeply knowledgeable about their way of life. Sarah and Ben quickly strike up a connection, and their growing chemistry adds a layer of tension to the story. Despite their differences, the two find common ground in their shared goal of helping Sarah’s family business thrive.

Together, they embark on a mission to create an Amish Christmas cookbook. They start by compiling recipes passed down through generations, weaving in stories and traditions that reflect the warmth and simplicity of Amish life. As Sarah works alongside Ben, she begins to rediscover the values she left behind—family, community, and the beauty of living simply. The process of creating the cookbook becomes more than just a professional project for Sarah; it becomes a journey of personal rediscovery and healing.

Ben, who has his own complicated past, finds solace in the quiet traditions of the Amish and is drawn to Sarah’s passion for the project. The more time they spend together, the stronger their bond becomes, leading them to consider the possibility of a future that blends their two very different worlds.

As Christmas approaches, Sarah and Ben’s cookbook takes shape, offering not just a collection of delicious recipes but also a glimpse into a life filled with love, faith, and community. The project helps save the bakery and gives Sarah a renewed sense of purpose in both her personal and professional life. But as the holiday season draws near, Sarah is left to wonder whether she is ready to embrace a life that includes not just her career in New York, but perhaps a future with Ben and a deeper connection to her Amish heritage.

This heartwarming story is a celebration of love, tradition, and the power of food to bring people together. It reminds us that sometimes, the most unexpected journeys lead to the most fulfilling discoveries.

Director: Jeff Hale

Genre: Drama, Romance, TV Movie

Cast: Alexandra Harris, Brandon Fox, Emma Henderson, Francesca Barker McCormick, G. Michael Nicolosi, Sean Koetting